Saturday, 22 November 2014

Review: Leica V-Lux (Typ 114)

Review: Leica V-Lux (Typ 114)

Introduction and features


Leica and Panasonic have an interesting working relationship. Some Panasonic cameras have Leica lenses that are produced in Panasonic's factory following Leica quality control measures. And some Panasonic cameras are essentially rebadged as Leica models. The V-Lux (Typ 114), for example is Leica's version of the popular Panasonic FZ1000 and like the D-Lux (aka Panasonic LX100), it's produced in Panasonic's factory.


Both have been covered already along with all the other latest camera reviews and news in the Techradar Camera Channel home page.


The (Typ 114), by the way, distinguishes the V-Lux from its predecessor, which was called the V-Lux 4 (confusingly) but was based on an the older Panasonic FZ200 bridge camera which has a smaller sensor.


As usual there is a price premium to pay for the Leica badge, but the V-Lux comes with a 3-year warrantee from Leica and a copy of Lightroom 5 for organising and processing your images.


Like the FZ1000, the V-Lux (Typ 114) is a bridge camera with a 16x zoom range and a focal length equivalent to 25-400mm. Both cameras have a Leica DC Vario-Elmarit lens with a maximum aperture of f/2.8 at the widest point and f/4 at the narrowest.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114)


Just like the FZ1000, the V-Lux is a direct competitor to the Sony RX10 which also has a (20.2Mp) 1-inch sensor, but the Sony's focal length range is restricted to the equivalent of 24-200mm, although the maximum aperture is a constant f/2.8 throughout the zoom range – the V-Lux's maximum aperture drops to f/4 at the equivalent of 175mm.


Inside the body is a 1-inch sensor (significantly larger than the 1/2.3-inch devices in most models), with 20.1 million pixels. The bigger sensor means larger photo-receptors, to allow more light to be captured and improve noise control, dynamic range and image quality as a whole.


Leica doesn't actually mention the V-Lux's processing engine, but it's a safe bet that it's the same Venus Engine as is found in the Panasonic FZ1000. This allows the native sensitivity to be set in the range ISO 80-12,500 with an expansion setting of ISO 25,000 – that's slightly different from the FZ1000 which tops out at ISO 12,800.The maximum continuous shooting speed is 12 frames per second.


There are exposure modes to suit enthusiasts (program, aperture priority, shutter priority and manual) along with a fully automatic mode and scene modes to help less experienced photographers. The V-Lux also has a mode that gives access to the same 22 filter effects available on the FZ1000. These effects are applied to JPEG files, but they can be used when shooting raw files simultaneously so that a clean file is available for processing.


The FZ1000 was the first bridge camera capable of 4K (3840 x 2160 pixel) video recording at up to 25fps (PAL) in MP4 format, and the V-Lux follows suit. While this may not impress some stills photographers, the fact that it's possible to extract 8Mp still images form 4K video may.


It's also possible to record video at Full HD and VGA resolution, but the V-Lux only allows MP4 recording while the FZ1000 can record in MP4 or AVCHD. The FZ1000's ability to record Full HD footage at 100fps is also absent in the V-Lux.


Like the FZ1000, the V-Lux has a collection of AF point selection options including, 49-Area, 1-Area AF, Pinpoint AF, Face Detection AF and the Custom Multi AF mode first seen in the GH4 that allows the user to select blocks, rows or columns of AF points for use. It's also possible to focus manually and Focus Peaking is available to show the areas of highest contrast (focus) – this is especially useful during video recording.


There is also a Zebra display for highlighting areas close to burning out. This can be set to indicate a brightness value of 50-105%.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114)


Naturally, as it's a bridge camera, the V-Lux's viewfinder is electronic rather than optical. This is a 2,359,000-dot OLED device, and there's a vari-angle 3-inch 921,000-dot LCD. As on the FZ1000, this screen is not touch-sensitive.


The V-Lux has Wi-Fi and NFC connectivity built-in for connecting to smartphones and tablets. In addition, Leica offers a free app (Image Shuttle) which enables the camera to be controlled remotely and images transferred wirelessly.


An intervalometer for time lapse recording, multiple exposure mode and a built-in flash, along with a hot-shoe for attaching an external flashgun, top-off the V-Lux's specification nicely.


Build and handling


Bridge cameras have grown in size in recent years, perhaps to convey a greater sense of gravitas, but the V-Lux (Typ 114) is one of the larger models around. Like the Panasonic FZ1000, it's a little larger than the Sony RX10, but it also has a much longer lens (albeit with a smaller maximum aperture at longer focal lengths). Neither the FZ1000 nor the V-Lux have quite the same high quality feel as the RX10.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114)


Although the V-Lux is reasonably solid for a bridge camera and is very similar in appearance to the FZ100, there are a few design touches that make it feel a little different in the hand. The Leica camera is just a tad more angular in appearance than the Panasonic camera and instead of the bottom edges being rounded, they are chamfered. It isn't a major issue, but this makes the camera a little less comfortable in the hand.


The textured coatings on the front and rear grips of the Leica camera also aren't quite as grippy as on the Panasonic model. Plus, the coating on the back doesn't extend quite so far around the thumb-ridge and this makes the camera feel a little less secure in the hand.


There are no changes to the control layout, however, and the V-Lux has a fairly extensive collection of buttons and dials giving a direct route to key features.


There's a mode dial on top of the camera that can be used to set the camera to shoot in aperture priority, shutter priority or manual exposure mode, or one of the Automatic or Scene modes. The point marked COL gives access to Creative Control mode and the 22 digital filter effects, including Sepia, High Dynamic, Toy Pop, Rough Monochrome, Soft Focus and Miniature Effect.


Like the FZ1000, there's a deep zoom ring around the lens barrel, but it isn't always convenient to use it to zoom from 25 to 400mm. Instead, I found that I often used the sprung switch around the shutter release to make major adjustments, while the ring is handy for minor tweaks to the framing.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114)


This ring can also be used to focus manually and there's a switch on the side of the barrel that allows you to switch between zooming and focusing. I found that there were very few occasions when I needed to focus manually because the autofocus system is very good, but Leica enthusiasts may feel more comfortable with manual focus. If they do, as well as the Focus Peaking display, the camera can be set to magnify a section of the scene to make it easier to assess focus.


I found that the 2,359,000-dot OLED electronic viewfinder (EVF) gives a good, clear view and changes made to the exposure or colour settings are quickly reflected in the image it displays. The rear screen, which has 921,000 dots also gives a clear, detailed view and its articulating joint means it is useful for composing images at above or below head-height. It's a shame the screen isn't touch-sensitive though as this would make it much easier to set the AF point, especially when shooting from awkward angles.


The electronic level which can be displayed in the EVF and rear screen is especially useful when shooting from unusual angles and you need to keep the horizon level, but it can be tricky to see on the screen in some situations – especially in bright conditions.


By default in 1-Area AF mode the desired point is set by tapping the left navigation key to access the AF point selection options, tapping the down key and then using the navigation controls to highlight the point. I activated the Direct Focus Area option in the custom menu to speed the process up by allowing the navigation keys to set the AF point directly. Unfortunately this means that their shortcut options (ISO, white balance and macro mode) are not accessible, but they can be reached via the Quick Menu.


The Quick Menu can be left in its default set-up or customised. I prefer to customise it so that I can access the options I want without having to scroll through features I rarely use. The customisation is easy, but once features have been assigned a position in this menu, the only way to reposition them is to delete them from it and then add them again.


Conveniently, there are a few options such as the drive mode and focus mode that can be set via dials and without delving into either the main or Quick menu. This speeds things up considerably. I also found it useful to set the Custom shooting modes (accessed via the mode dial) so that I could quickly switch between my preferred set-ups. You just need to remember that any features that need to be set via dials (such as the drive mode) will not be changed.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114)


Leica has used the same menu arrangement for the V-Lux as Panasonic has for the FZ1000, but rather than highlighting the selected option, it is underlined in red. There's also the same Menu Guide with it's rather variable degree of assistance. For example, if you try to access the HDR (high dynamic range) feature when recording raw files (or raw and JPEG files simultaneously) it shows the option as greyed out. There's no explanation that this is a JPEG-only option and that to access it you first need to turn off raw recording. It also doesn't explain why you might select features like the electronic or mechanical shutter (maximum shutter speed rises to 1/16000sec with the electronic shutter), it just informs you which option will be selected by each setting. It's not so much helping you decide what to do, as confirming that you are doing what you are doing.


Performance


My first impressions of the V-Lux were very good. It's clearly capable of capturing high quality images with pleasant colours and a decent level of detail. Raw files in particular impress with their dynamic range and the ability to draw back detail from areas that initially look burned out.


However, the multi-purpose metering system throws up a few surprises. On some occasions it delivers perfectly exposed results, but on others it delivers very bright images. In some situations during this test the exposure needed to be reduced by 1EV or more, without any logical reason – the AF point was on a midtone and the iDynamic dynamic range optimisation system was switched off.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


This was shot using the exposure settings suggested by the camera and looks too bright. Click here for a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


Reducing the exposure by 1EV has produced a more pleasing image that better reflects the shooting conditions at the time. Click here for a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


Another rather bright image. Click here for a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


This time reducing the exposure by 2/3EV has produced a more natural result. Click here for a full resolution version.


Thankfully the electronic viewfinder (EVF) and screen on the back of the camera do a good job of representing the image as it will be captured. So if the image is going to be too bright you will see it before the shot is taken. There's also a histogram view and the Zebra view to assist with this. However, when set to show areas at 100% brightness, the Zebra display is a little over-enthusiastic and tends to indicate more will be white than actually is.


Images produced using the default 'Standard' Photo Style have pleasant colours and a pleasing level of mid-tone contrast. Simultaneously captured raw files look a little flat and lacking in saturation, but are ripe for processing.


It's interesting to compare images from the V-Lux with those from the Panasonic FZ1000. At the lower sensitivity settings the Leica camera produces JPEGs that look a fraction more natural at 100% than those from the Panasonic model. Details are slightly sharper and out of focus areas appear more naturally soft. These differences, which indicate that Leica has chosen the in-camera processing, become less noticeable as sensitivity rises. The Leica camera's processing seems to handle out of focus areas a little better, although there's not much in it. At normal viewing sizes the JPEG images are hard to tell apart.


Panasonic and Leica provide different raw file processing software and this may have an impact upon how the raw files appear direct from the cameras and after processing. However, when raw files from the two cameras are processed in the same way using Adobe Camera Raw, they look the same.


Processing raw files post capture brings the ability to apply as much or as little noise reduction as you like to preserve detail. At normal viewing sizes the V-Lux produces decent looking images throughout its native sensitivity range (ISO 80-12,500). Zoom into 100%, however, and there's a faint granular texture visible in some areas even at low sensitivity settings such as ISO 400. This luminance noise becomes more visible along with chroma noise as sensitivity rises (when all noise reduction is turned off). By ISO 3200 there's some softening apparent in JPEGs, and smudging of details captured in JPEGs captured at ISO 6400.


The V-Lux's automatic white balance (AWB) system performs well in most natural light conditions, producing images that represent the shooting conditions well. Under overcast skies the atmosphere of the weather conditions is visible, but the images don't look excessively cold or blue. Similarly, images taken in full sunlight look warm, but not too yellow.


As with the FZ1000, chromatic aberration is controlled well and distortion isn't a major issue at any point in the lens's focal length range.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


The AF system had no trouble getting this bird sharp as long as it stayed on its perch. The detail around the eye is good, but the complex patterns of the feathers on the back of the bird look rather painterly. Click here for a full resolution version.


The V-Lux is capable of focusing quickly even in quite low light and it can keep a moving subject sharp provided that the active AF point is kept over the target. The Tracking AF system, however, is useless with anything other than slow moving subjects. It doesn't respond quickly enough to movements around the frame or to changes in subject distance.


Image quality and resolution


As part of our image quality testing for the Leica V-Lux (Typ 114), we've shot our resolution chart.


Click here to see a full explanation of what our resolution charts mean.


Examining images of the chart taken at each sensitivity setting reveals the following resolution scores in line widths per picture height x100:


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


Full ISO 100 image. See 100% crops below:


JPEG


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 100: Score 26. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 200: Score 26. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 400: Score 22. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 800: Score 22. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 1600: Score 22. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 3200: Score 20. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 6400: Score 22. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 12500: Score 22. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 25000: Score 22. Click here for full resolution version.


Raw (converted to TIFF)


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 100: Score 28. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 200: Score 28. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 400: Score 26. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 800: Score 24. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 1600: Score 24. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 3200: Score 22. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 6400: Score 22. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 12500: Score 22. Click here for full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) resolution


ISO 25000: Score 22. Click here for full resolution version.


Noise and dynamic range


We shoot a specially designed chart in carefully controlled conditions and the resulting images are analysed using DXO Analyzer software to generate the data to produce the graphs below.


The four rival cameras we chose for this comparison are the Panasonic FZ1000, Sony RX10 and Canon SX60 HS.


A high signal to noise ratio (SNR) indicates a cleaner and better quality image.


For more more details on how to interpret our test data, check out our full explanation of our noise and dynamic range tests.


JPEG dynamic range


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) dynamic range


Analysis: Interestingly, the dynamic range of the V-Lux (Typ 114) does differ from that of the Panasonic FZ1000, the camera it's based on – this seems to confirm our impression that there are differences in the image processing. At lower ISOs the Leica's performance is average and below the FZ1000's, but at ISO 1600 and beyond the tables are turned, and the V-Lux puts in the best performance.


Raw (converted to TIFF) dynamic range


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) dynamic range


Analysis: The RAW files tell a different story. Here, the figures for the Panasonic FZ1000 and Leica V-Lux are almost identical. All four cameras in this comparison show similar results at ISO 100-200, but beyond that the smaller sensor Canon falls away rapidly, as we would expect.


JPEG signal to noise ratio


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) signal to noise ratio


Analysis: The three cameras with 1-inch sensors easily outperform the Canon SX60 HS, demonstrating the value of a larger sensor. The Sony proves better at handling noise in JPEG images at ISO 1600 and beyond, while the Panasonic and Leica produce identical results.


Raw (converted to TIFF) signal to noise ratio


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) signal to noise ratio


Analysis: The signal to noise results are broadly the same for raw files, though here the Panasonic FZ1000 and Sony RX10 prove the most closely matched, with the Leica V-Lux falling slightly behind at higher ISOs. The Canon's data again shows the disadvantages of a small sensor.


Sensitivity and noise images


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


Full ISO 100 image. See 100% crops below:


JPEG


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 100. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 200. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 400. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 800. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 1600. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 3200. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 6400. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 12500. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 25000. Click here for full-resolution image.


Raw (converted to TIFF)


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 100. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 200. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 400. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 800. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 1600. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 3200. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 6400. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 12500. Click here for full-resolution image.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) ISO sensitivity


ISO 25000. Click here for full-resolution image.


Sample images


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


The vari-angle screen is useful when you want to shoot from low angles like this. Click here to see a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


There's an impressive level of detail in this shot and the focus falls away naturally. Click here for a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


Shooting at the longest point of the lens and f/5 has blurred the background nicely. Click here for a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


Taken at the shortest point of the lens. Click here for a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


Taken from the same position as the previous image but at the longest point of the lens. Click here for a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


The automatic white balance system has produced a natural looking result in the overcast conditions of this scene. Click here for a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


The V-Lux's long zoom is useful for candid shots and the wide aperture (this was taken at 300mm and f/4) blurs backgrounds nicely. Click here for a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


The colour and detail of this back-lit JPEG image are very natural. Click here for a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


All noise reduction has been turned off when processing this ISO 1600 raw file to reveal the chroma noise in some mid-tone-to-dark areas. Click here for a full resolution version.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114) sample image


This is the same shot with bespoke noise reduction applied. The coloured speckling is hidden to leave only luminance noise and plenty of detail. Click here for a full resolution version.


Verdict


A major part of the appeal of bridge cameras is their wide focal length range without the need to swap lenses. With a 16x zoom (25-400mm), the V-Lux doesn't offer the greatest range of a bridge camera, but it is still extremely versatile. Its widest point is suitable for landscapes, interiors and documentary photography, while the telephoto end is useful for capturing distant details and wildlife. And provided you can keep the active AF point over the subject, it's a good optic for shooting sport.


Leica V-Lux (Typ 114)


Other manufacturers that have more extensive zoom ranges achieve the headline figure by using a smaller sensor. This has negative repercussions for image quality and encourages the photographer to zoom rather than move to explore the subject and find a better shooting angle.


The comparatively large maximum aperture throughout the V-Lux's focal length range is also very attractive, bringing the ability to control depth of field for creative blurring of backgrounds as well as enabling safe handholding shutter speeds in low light.


Leica's history lies in stills photography and even its most highly prized cameras like the Leica M and Monochrom have a stripped down specification that focuses on the most important aspects of the medium. The company's association with Panasonic, however, brings the V-Lux some up to the minute features including the ability to record 4K video. The fact that this allows 8Mp stills to be extracted is probably anathema to the dyed-in-the-wool Leica followers, but it could prove useful to inexperienced and experimental photographers.


We liked


The main selling points of the V-Lux and FZ1000 are their larger than average (1-inch type) sensor, the high quality Leica lens with a 16x zoom range and the SLR-like controls. The V-Lux is more expensive than the FZ1000 but it has a three year guarantee, which will be a comfort to many, and it is supplied with Adobe Lightroom. Lightroom is an excellent image organisation and editing software package, but it's worth noting that it now comes bundled with Photoshop CC as part of the Adobe Photographers' Program available for £8.78/$9.99 per month.


Like the FZ1000, the V-Lux has a very good electronic viewfinder that is capable of showing plenty of detail with no flickering or banding. There's also the helpful Focus Peaking display to guide manual focusing.


We disliked


While Leica doesn't normally employ fancy features like touchscreens, Panasonic usually does. This makes it strange that neither the FZ1000 nor the V-Lux have a touchscreen. It's a shame as it would make setting AF point a little quicker and setting adjustments would be made more intuitive.


It would also be nice to have the ability to shoot raw files when using HDR mode and have control over exposure in the Creative Control options.


Verdict


The Panasonic FZ1000 is an excellent bridge camera and the Leica V-Lux is almost exactly the same for a bit more money. The JPEG files that it produces look a little better when viewed at 100% on screen, but the differences are minor at normal viewing sizes. The raw files from the two cameras appear identical when processed using the same software.


Although the V-Lux is nicely constructed, it lacks the high quality feel of the Sony RX10. It's also not quite as comfortable in the hand as the FZ1000.


While the large size of the V-Lux provides a decent amount of space for your hand, it is less portable than some smaller bridge, compact system cameras and compact cameras. It's so close in size and design to a small SLR that I'd advise potential purchasers to take a good look at cameras like the Nikon D3300, which could be paired with a superzoom lens with a focal length range of 18-200mm (27-300mm effective on APS-C format) or even 18-300mm (27-450mm). A compact system camera like the Panasonic G6 could also make an attractive alternative. Both of these cameras have larger sensors, which brings better image quality. They also accept interchangeable lenses.


That said, many users opt for a bridge camera to avoid the concern of lens selection. These users will find the V-Lux an excellent camera that has lots of scope for taking control if you want to while providing automatic options for those who want the camera to do the thinking. Whether or not it is worth the extra money in comparison with the FZ1000 depends upon whether you want the security of a three year warrantee and the ability to process raw (and JPEG) files using Adobe Lightroom.




















from TechRadar: Technology reviews http://ift.tt/1qNzOcC

No comments:

Post a Comment

Back to top ↑
Connect with Us

    Popular Posts

    Powered by Blogger.

    Pages

    About

What they says

© 2013 techmobile. WP Mythemeshop Converted by Bloggertheme9
Blogger templates. Proudly Powered by Blogger.